An introduction to Constitutional Law 100 Supreme Court cases everyone should know

Randy E. Barnett & Josh Blackman

Al Smith lost his job as a drug-abuse counselor due to his use of peyote. He ingested the hallucinogenic cactus as part of a ritual in the Native American Church. Oregon denied unemployment benefits to Smith because he was “discharged for work-related ‘misconduct’”—that is, using an illegal controlled substance.

The Oregon courts ruled that the Employment Division was required to exempt Smith from its generally applicable law, and grant him unemployment benefits. The state appealed the case to the Supreme Court. The question presented was “whether Oregon’s criminal law against the use of certain mind-altering drugs including peyote, can constitutionally be applied to the respondent’s sacramental use of peyote in ceremonies of the Native American Church.”

The Supreme Court reversed, and ruled against Smith. Justice Scalia wrote the majority opinion.

Three ways to watch and read


The classic paperback edition with access to video library



Elegant hardcover volume with 500 distinctive photographs


Bulk Purchases

Short-term licenses for classes, schools, and districts