An introduction to Constitutional Law 100 Supreme Court cases everyone should know

Randy E. Barnett & Josh Blackman

Under New Jersey law, commissions on the sale of fire insurance policies were required to be “reasonable.” The O’Gorman firm sold Hartford Fire Insurance policies. Their contract provided that the commissions would be priced at “what such services were reasonably worth.” O’Gorman asserted that its commission was “reasonably worth” 25 percent of the insurance premiums. Hartford, however, only paid a 20 percent commission. O’Gorman filed suit for breach of contract. The trial court found that under New Jersey law, a 25 percent commission was unreason- able and could not be paid.

O’Gorman appealed the case to the Supreme Court. The firm argued that the regulation deprived the company of property—that is, the extra commission— without the due process of law.

Three ways to watch and read

Videos Only

Binge watch the 12-hour video library


Videos + E-Book

Instantly access the video library and download the E-Book


Videos + Paperback

Read the paperback and stream the videos